Ben's Blog

Use the search by date, or the page numbers on the bottom of the screen to search for posts as far back as 2010

  • Post Date

The Output is Inevitable

“In every single class when you are giving CI instruction, interacting in fun and unforced ways with the kids, the output is inevitable.” Linda Li  

Read More »

The End of Motivation

The End of Motivation Stephen Krashen New Routes, vol 55: 34-35. 2015 www.disal.com.br/newr/ I announce in this paper the end of motivation as a relevant factor in language education. I announce in this paper the

Read More »

Lowering of the Affective Filter

In my ongoing work at AES with Steven Cook, we have been exploring Krashen’s Affective Filter Hypothesis as it may apply to ELA instruction. A summary of that work, a result of about six weeks

Read More »

Materials To Share

These are from Angie: Hi Ben! I wanted to share some materials I made this week in case anyone is in need of a quick filler lesson…. It’s for a MovieTalk of this trailer from

Read More »

Differentiation for Gifted Kids?

From John Piazza: There has been a lot of discussion on the list about dealing with 4%ers, but I would like to take the conversation in perhaps a different direction, which may help me in

Read More »

Eight Traps – Draft #2

Hi Ben, Thanks to the feedback from the PLC, I have revised the Eight Traps document, adding some additional information, names, and sources. Here it is. Robert Opponents of Teaching with Comprehensible Input in general

Read More »

Summary of Big Bad Boy Steps

Of course this is much more than can be done in two blocks. More like 10. But it gives the sequence, a very valuable one in my opinion that has been cooking for at least

Read More »

Big Bad Boy Two Week Lesson Plan

I like lesson plans that are rugged and tough and yet that have lots of flex in them so that if something is working we can stay with it as long as we like. It’s

Read More »

Live A Little With Grammar

I am and will always remain of the firm and studied opinion that grammar teachers secretly hate their jobs and yearn for something exciting but are afraid to leave the shores of book safety that

Read More »

Report from the Field – Ben Slavic

As mentioned here a week ago, there is a new arrangement with the story artist. Perhaps it’s the iPad with so many bells and whistles  that causes the artist to disappear into the iPad and thus

Read More »

Eight Traps – Draft #1

Here is the draft from Robert: In a recent discussion with other teachers, one of the participants expressed the following opinion in opposing Teaching with Comprehensible Input: “If you teach like a baby learns its

Read More »

Report from the Field – 1- Robert Harrell

Hi Everyone, Last Thursday I was at a District World Languages Department Chair meeting. The TOSA (Teacher on Special Assignment) opened a discussion about language acquisition. During the discussion, classroom practice came up. One of

Read More »

Dual Entry Journal Form

Diane mentioned Bryce’s Dual Line Reading Entry form. It is to be used with oppositionally defiant kids (or anyone else) whom we have separated out from the class in another classroom because they can’t behave.

Read More »

Use of Instructional Minutes

I’m reposting this because the issue of blurting just came up as a thread. I have to say that this plan is better than any I have ever used to control blurting. Today it worked

Read More »

Blurting Strategy

Here’s an idea from Eric someone may like to try out: Hey Ben: Quick strategy I’m trying this year and having success with thus far: Kids sit in chairs in a semi-circle with a few

Read More »

Input First

From Eric: Check out Jim Trelease’s image: https://app.box.com/s/42shyfan0x5p754wsr71/1/1189482717/14395317372/1

Read More »

Linda Li on Running Dictation

Running dictation is such a good way to give kids a break from lots of input. Linda did a running dictation class today and it was during my planning period so I was able to

Read More »

Eric's Test Sequence

Eric is testing a sequence of high frequency verbs. Here is the link: https://benslavic.com/blog/a-good-ideateaching-hf-verbs/ I have been using this. It is really good. I just take the sheet and hold it in my hand as

Read More »

What Are We Doing?

I was just talking with Linda Li and she told me that ten years ago in China she tried a yoga class, her first ever, and it was at the wrong level. She said that

Read More »

Awesome Free Write Assessment Materials

Steven Ordiano in Fresno CA has given us some really great free write materials. One is a form for free writes and the other is an assessment instrument that resembles OWATS: FluencyWrite FluencyWriteAnalysis  

Read More »

Bail Out Move

I don’t even know if this one is even listed in our list of bail out moves. It’s really simple. Whenever we need to bail out (when the CI is sluggish and we feel kind

Read More »

We Teach Verbs

It occurred to me that some of the newer people in our group may not know what our curriculum looks like. In a word, we teach verbs. We don’t teach a mosh pit of intellectual/academic

Read More »

They Forget Content

Our students forget content but they remember language. It’s a big joke that people are hired to teach kids things that they will definitely forget after the test, things that will have zero use to

Read More »

The Most Important Thing

  This story from Jim Tripp has an elegant simplicity in the structure. The one I am going to do with the Skyped in kid from Japan may be too complex. I am glad Jim

Read More »

Linda Li on Question Words in Chinese

Some more details/clarifications from Linda Li on the current discussion about question words: I have two sets of Question words (Pinyin, and characters. Both posted in my classroom. Depending where they sit in the classroom

Read More »

The Student Was Right

A student studied long and hard for a (memorized material) Spanish test. The test came and the student was upset that the test was too easy – he studied far more than he needed to,

Read More »

Lost Something of Great Importance

Next week one of my students has to go to Japan for the week. I’m going to Skype him into our classes because he doesn’t want to miss class. We’ll beam him in from Japan

Read More »

No More Question Words Except in Chinese?

Ruth and I had a side conversation in the comment fields earlier tonight about question words in relation to the overall discussion about Linda Li’s recent Two Truths and a Lie classes here in our school,

Read More »

Amelia Earhart

There is a poignant scene toward the end of the film Night at the Museum when Amelia Earhart whispers into Ben Stiller’s character’s ear, “Have fun!” before flying off in her red airplane. It reminds

Read More »

Polly Fuller on Assessment

Every one in a while a sentence rings true. This from Polly, in just a few words, lays to complete waste everything that has ever been said about assessment: …I really feel like those kids

Read More »

Double Bubble

Nathaniel responds below to some verbage from somewhere. We don’t need to know where, just some sad educational factory place where people write stuff that they don’t really understand but do it because it sounds

Read More »

An Indictment

This, from John Bracey, is telling. It is almost the equivalent of a criminal indictment on grammar teachers. It really burns me up: I remember having a conversation with some upper level high school students

Read More »

CI Across the Curriculum

A science teacher is using CI strategies to teach science. Linda sent this to me – it was on Facebook. Yes it’s also a shameless plug for my new book: …today, a young 9th grade

Read More »

In The Manner Of A Bygone Era

A repost for Keri: A person I know recently brought up some concerns about the 1950’s style of textbook based/thematic unit memorization of lists teaching going on in a certain school. This person made all

Read More »

Tough Question

This one is from Keri: Hi Ben, I have a question that maybe the PLC could help me with.  Last year was my first “TPRS” year and, of course, those students are with other teachers.

Read More »

Been Wondering

Why would a person look at a book or interact with a computer to learn a language? It strikes me as a very good thing that CI teachers have as their goal each day to

Read More »

Brother Molière

When we create discussion in stories, we can exaggerate one of the qualities of each actor. This can be done using the Director’s Cues. When an actor is really exaggerating one single human quality, it

Read More »

Writing Assessment

What if we just did a Free Write Portfolio as our summative assessment each semester? We could use the OWATS model. Then we wouldn’t have to formally test writing each semester with some stupid test,

Read More »

Question

Q. True or False: Assessment is an essential component of the learning process.

Read More »

Question

Q. Is it more important to focus on and use strategies that bring the greatest gains or strategies that focus on keeping the kids’ interest high? A. When the kids’ interest is the highest, the

Read More »

John Bracey on Grammar

From John Piazza: On Latin Best Practices today, John Bracey shared some real insight about the traditional way of teaching grammar. It certainly resonates with my experience, as both teacher and learner of Latin: “I

Read More »

Sandbox – 1

Kids play in sandboxes. To them, when they are in a sandbox, even if they are doing “work” (building a sand castle, making something out of sticks), to them it’s still play. What about us?

Read More »

Finding Our Personal Power

James Hosler shares an important moment from yesterday in his Latin classes: I just kicked a kid out of my last class of the day. I hate doing that, but he just wouldn’t shut up.

Read More »

A Good Idea/Teaching HF Verbs

Eric is in the process of trying out a new idea to teach high frequency verbs. I thought that if some others of us in the group tried it as well we could give him some

Read More »

TPR Breakthrough

From Brother Eric: Gotta post a TPR breakthrough! I tried how Asher teaches TPR –https://youtu.be/KmfnrYerYbY – the teacher demoing with 2 students, the rest of the class observing. Wow, did this make classroom management easier,

Read More »

Cement Your Ankles

Pour some concrete into your shoes. Or attach a 20 lb. ankle weight on each ankle. Take a sentence: Jacob was born on Sept. 29, 2011. Walk to Jacob. It will take a while because

Read More »

Move Things Along

We sometimes get bogged down when getting details via circling during stories. We get too many details. Details are great – they flush out the spatial imagery of the story. But they shouldn’t overshadow its

Read More »