Ben's Blog

Use the search by date, or the page numbers on the bottom of the screen to search for posts as far back as 2010

  • Post Date

All That Grammar

From Bob Patrick: Interesting (though not at all surprising) tidbit here today.  I have a female student, Latin 2, who was “sent away” to a juvenile institution to deal with behavioral issues (at home –

Read More »

Options for Kids

Here is that information from Jim that he sent to jen about options available to those few kids in class who want something else. Jim, are we to understand that these are for levels 3 and above

Read More »

Positive News

Those following the Jeff Brickler thread here will be heartened to read this from some parents to Jeff: Dear Mr. Brickler, David is lucky  to be your student and has been enjoying your teaching and studying

Read More »

Just Play Defense 1

In some classes, like the one Jeff is dealing with right now, you just have to give up the lofty goals of heavy input CI and punt the ball, just to make it to the

Read More »

We Will Prevail

I want to keep the blog apolitical. Real life (the shootings) intruded, and we rightly needed to talk. I went numb, we all did, and something in me and in many of us will never

Read More »

Thomas Merton

Thomas Merton said what is below. It first appeared here in 2007. I think it’s a good time to republish it here in the light of some of us here having made the significant decision

Read More »

Jeff 3

Jeff is really a kind of lightning rod in our village. He has now been hit again. The image is one of a boxer taking another roundhouse to the head. No mistake about it –

Read More »

Long Term Leave Question

Erin asks the group: Ben, I have a question I’d like to ask the group.  I’ll be missing the last 5 weeks of school this spring (if not longer) to have my first baby.  What

Read More »

Break Time

Let’s take a break. I’m not interested in thinking about how to become a better teacher right now. I don’t think you are either. Let’s pick this ball up again in January – that would

Read More »

The Tragedy

Think of this post as a place to say or not say what we are thinking and feeling, if we have not gone numb, right now. We work in schools. Our lives are around children.

Read More »

Writing Template 2 – kWT

Today Diana Noonan came by and saw me using bWT. She didn’t like it. She said that the story we wrote together was more about production and critical thinking and so did not go along

Read More »

I Wanted to Stay

Today one of my classes ended with my group of kids having created the following text as per bWT. We were working from a prompt of three couples dancing at a party: There were three girls and four

Read More »

Subatomic Mass

We should respect what goes on in the deeper mind as it does its work of creating language systems. We should listen to TPRS/CI experts like Judy Dubois when they speak like this: …it seems

Read More »

The Round World Group

Jody La Maréchale des Forces de l’Ouest said in an email: I think we should name ourselves “The Round World Group”. I can no longer see my work through the “flat world lens” no matter

Read More »

The Work

How beautiful this is from Jody, our Maréchale of the Western Forces: I notice how easily we “change course” trying to manage our own personalities, histories, perceived weaknesses, anxiety/fears about our job security, etc., and

Read More »

Writing Template 1 – bWT

The listening input we provide for our students is not a set of activities but rather a process based on a template (we call it the first two steps of TPRS). In the same way, the

Read More »

Another Writing Idea

This writing idea is from a teacher in Robert’s school: Our French teacher is also an English teacher, and she showed us a way to nudge our students along in writing and give them the

Read More »

Personalized Spinouts in R and D

It’s weird how we can work with this comprehensible input for years and not see things right under our noses. The idea of doing R and D as per recent comments here by Jody, where

Read More »

Output Question

A group member asks: …where can I find ammo on the blog that has to do with why forcing output does not lead to acquisition?… Any ideas?

Read More »

ELA Thoughts

I was talking with one our AP’s today who is bright and actually sat in on the classes I did with Krashen here last year. She gets it. She was ALL OVER the jGR and

Read More »

Structured Input 2

Here is more of the conversation between the Structured Input person at the U of Maine (comments in black) and skip (comments in blue). The first article is here: https://benslavic.com/blog/2012/12/09/structured-input/ Kathleen, Thank you for your

Read More »

Report from the Field – Jeff Brickler

Another series of emails, the third such collection, among the Latinists, but it applies to all of us. It is about Jeff’s organizing himself against attacks by ignorant people, but there is also a valuable

Read More »

Which Word Means ____ ?

The essence of pop up grammar in R and D is to simply say, “X means ____ “. If a kid asks something about X and Gammar Man inside of us wants to go off

Read More »

Other Methods – Some Terminology

Robert gave a nice rundown of some terms that are thrown around a lot in language circles. Below he explains these terms to Chris, who right now is the kid enjoying challenging the emperors on

Read More »

Structured Input 1

A U-Maine French professor wrote a text on input that caught skip’s attention, who shared it with me. My opinion is that this professor would fail badly in secondary schools, and that she likely reaches a lot less

Read More »

Sabrina’s Writing Idea (sWI)

Heh heh. I just keep coming up with these annoying acronyms. Here’s another one – sabrina’s Writing Idea, or sWI. It is an excellent idea and easily put in place just by extending a story class by

Read More »

Question from Chris

Chris needs answers from the group: Ben, I was thinking, I could use some definitions of some terms we throw around.  We obviously know what somebody means when they say CI or TPRS but, I

Read More »

David’s Reading Plan – dRP

I had asked David to write out a description of his plan with examples just to make it more clear. The original discussion a week ago was here: https://benslavic.com/blog/2012/12/01/embedded-reading-activity/ dRP (David’s Reading Plan): Day 1:

Read More »

Havin’ a Ball!

Remember when you were little and sometimes you played ball, learning about throwing and catching? You even threw it to people. And they caught it sometimes! And YOU caught it sometimes! Lets’ break that down in

Read More »

We Need Some Writing Ideas

Carol suggests that we talk about getting some ideas for writing. We don’t have many. It’s a good idea: ….when it comes to the baby steps of writing that eventually morph into the upper level

Read More »

Interview Your Kids During Novels

Jody does this thing where she interviews her kids. It’s a good one: I never “circle” in reading. (I have a lot of reasons for not doing it, but I don’t believe there are any

Read More »

Spreading the Wealth with jGR

This suggestion from Ben Lev addresses a problem that I am sure most of us have without even being aware of it: Yesterday in the middle of a story I was getting great response from

Read More »

Educational Entitlement for the Wealthy

A minor but super important thread to me in the past few weeks here has been the one on the rich wanting to hire their own Latin tutors and keeping instruction like it was in the 18th century.

Read More »

Scripting Stories

David’s brilliant idea also made me want to share what Anne wrote in the appendix to her story script books – a step by step way of scripting our own stories. Anne has always felt

Read More »

Erin Bas

We welcome Erin to the discussion and thank you for the bio, Erin: Ben, I joined your group a couple weeks ago, and I wanted to introduce myself and let you know what a fantastic

Read More »

Michael Fullan

Here is a repost of an article from 2009. I was reading some of Michael Fullan’s work and saw in it support of what we are going though in TPRS/CI. I am hearing from Fullan that: 1.

Read More »

Helena Curtain

Diane Neubauer wrote this here yesterday: I just attended a one-day conference with Helena Curtain as the speaker. She talked about the 90%+ guideline, why, and how to get through challenges to using the target

Read More »

Sabrina Joy Stevens

Highly recommended: http://www.alternet.org/news-amp-politics/watch-teacher-infiltrates-alec-education-meeting-confronts-members

Read More »

jGR December 2012 Version – Latest

I have made some changes to what I want jGR to be for me. If you don’t like the changes, just use the November version. This is the December version. The sentences I changed are

Read More »

Learning Lab Today

I hosted a DPS Learning Lab today and made a handout for the teachers to refer to during the observation. Here it is below in case anyone is interested. It’s basically the stuff I want

Read More »

Input Precedes Output

This is from skip, who welcomes feedback: In an attempt to further the “how do humans acquire second languages” discussion I would like to make the following statements: 1. Oral proficiency is produced by repetitive

Read More »

Red Tape Study Guides

A question from Melissa: Hi Ben, My principal just sent out an email asking for samples of our “study guides” for assessments when an individualized education plan or 504 plan requires it for the students.

Read More »

Parent Board Member

A question from Jen for the group. It’s about the parent re-education thing: Ben, This email, unlike my others, will be short. I’m just so damn tired. I had to make a call to a

Read More »

Let’s Talk More About Latin and CI

This is the position of ACTFL on learning classical languages (ACTFL Position Statement of 7/30/12): …communication for a classical language refers to an emphasis on reading ability….   Here is the link: http://www.actfl.org/news/position-statements/use-the-target-language-the-classroom John Piazza,

Read More »

Latin and Comprehensible Input

These articles by our own Robert Patrick and John Piazza fit in with the current thread started by David. I think that they are important for us to read, in case we get into discussion with any colleagues

Read More »