Checking For Understanding – We Verify By Asking More Y/N And One Word Answer Questions Than We Ever Thought We Could In A Million Years

To view this content, you must be a member of Ben's Patreon at $10 or more
Already a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to access this content.

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn

29 thoughts on “Checking For Understanding – We Verify By Asking More Y/N And One Word Answer Questions Than We Ever Thought We Could In A Million Years”

  1. Actually that was one of the BIG learnings for me week too while working with Susie. I was asking the “class” to gesture when they didn’t understand… Susie said she never does this because, as you say, kids lie (for a LOT of good reasons, I would argue)

    Anyway, for her this is precisely what contrastive grammar is for…. If we are teaching to the eyes we MUST sense that a kid is struggling and while pointing to the L2/English ask ¿Bobby, what would “carro azul” (low processer)mean? Tommy, what would “carro verde” (average processor) mean and Chad, how would you say “red elephant? (fast processor) This assures constant “understanding”…. It is super quick, and you can really get a flow going…..

    I left two students behind last year. I blamed them and their constant chatter but looking back on it I am sure they were chatting because I was NOT making sure they understood….

    One might wonder if this will BORE the fast processors…. that is the beauty of contrastive grammar, I can ask questions that push them and challenge them too…

    Finally, thank you Ben for your ongoing investment in us. The five hours you spend honing our skills and helping us become better classroom managers is SO appreciated by me. It absolutely blows me away that a group of 10-15 teachers would sit and learn for 3-5 hours AFTER 8 hours of workshops/coaching for MORE! It was a beautiful thing and I thank you.

    I was trying to think about what the greatest gift you have given me is… There really have been too many important ones to say, BUT, I do think the circling with props (I changed it from balls because of all the artists, readers, dancers in my room) is right up there. It has brought such a level of personalization and has enabled such a solid relationship with the class, that I think that is the ONE for me.

    And (really finally), it was SO wonderful to put faces to all the names on the PLC. John, David, Clarice, Sabrina, Erik, Shannon, Chill, and others)

    Anyway, that is enough for now. I want to reflect more later about different things including that moment I had in class with Erik but later….

    Thanks for your post and for your continued support.

    1. Sabrina Janczak

      Skip , it was indeed a great week and most importantly getting to put faces on names and bonding with all the people on this blog was very satisfying.
      I am not sure I understood contrastive grammar from Suzie Gross.
      Can you explain in your own words how you understood that?

  2. Yes, an awesome week, in large part because so many of us from this little community finally got to meet in person, and it was indeed a “mind meld” experience when we all started working and sharing ideas. Those late night “after-party” sessions really helped me get a lot of potential problems ironed out. While the entire conference was a great help in terms of tightening up our skills at doing the method, your primary contribution, Ben (And one which was not always understood or appreciated), was to get us all focused on the emotional energy underlying our classroom interactions, which is where it all happens, and what determines whether or not we have a successful year. At the beginning of the conference, I was focused on WHAT the presenters were doing, and WHAT I was doing, but by the end, I was sitting in presentations thinking: how is this making me FEEL as a student? Am I being acknowledged, or should I start messing around and talking to my neighbor?” And when I was working in small groups during coaching, I had evolved to see my students as emotional beings who needed something from me. Powerful stuff indeed.

    1. I don’t know if we can either but, I will tell you, what happened between me and Erik Wednesday night was a VERY powerful thing….. It gave me insight into what it is like to be a student more than anything else ever had…

      I would like to try to discuss it in writing…

      1. pleasepleaseplease “try to discuss it in writing!” i am really bummed to have missed all the action in las vegas, (haha, i was kind of near la vega in the dr, but entirely different scene!) so as much as possible i would love to glean some of this stuff vicariously through your processing and reflection!
        🙂

  3. I’m new to the group, to TPRS and CI, and to the high school where I’ll be teaching, and I’m learning so much by working my way through this blog and the many comments. This summer I’ve put myself through a crash course in TPRS, starting in June with Blaine’s workshop in Oklahoma City. When school starts in a few weeks (!) I think I’ll begin with circling with balls. Skip, I like your idea of other kinds of props. It makes sense that I could circle with a ball on Day 1, but after looking over the sketches of student interests, on Day 2 could begin bringing in other kinds of things as well.

  4. Yeah everybody needs to be clear that I do not favor athletes, it’s just that middle school is where I developed this idea and all kids or most of them play sports in middle school and I use the ball as a way of getting power over the athletes as described on the resource pages here because some athletes come into class on the first day determined to control part of the room and that right there ain’t gonna happen on my watch so the balls are very useful in that way. Skip is right to call it Circling with Props. Scott calls it Circling with Drawings or something like that. There are many variations on the idea and no one way to do this. And yes I honor and discuss my artists and my non athletes just as much. That term has been around for ten years and should not cause confusion.

  5. And, just to clarify, I do almost always do BALLS (sports) first because of the reasons you taught in your sessions in Maine. Win those athletes and you have won:)

    1. Thanks for the clarifications. I have a few balls ready to go, then I’ll work in some other props. Ben, I think you’re exactly right about the problem with verifying with fingers. In Blaine’s workshop I thought it sounded great, giving students that responsibility to interact and speak up for what they do and don’t understand. Then came a German presentation. The German was hard, and when the presenter asked for the show of fingers, five for high comprehension, I found myself thinking maybe two, three at the most. I glanced around to everyone holding up four and five. I didn’t want to be the slow one and delay the class. So I held up four and hoped to catch up later.

  6. Messy board, guilty! Must work on that. I learned this week that I don’t have to put up ANY out of bounds words on the board – maybe one or two if they are high frequency. Ben, thanks for highlighting this fundamental skill. Now, how to make it artful and not predictable. Great seeing so many faces from the blog over the last two weeks.

  7. And Carol did you notice my board for the kids at Breckenridge and then on Tues. at NTPRS? Messy City. And then on Thursday for Lazy? Neat City. What is the difference? How did that happen? Why was Thursday’s story (Lazy) ten times better than anything in both conferences?

    It is a result of doing what I describe in the above article. It’s why Linda Li’s board is never messy. She is a charter and founding member of the Never Messy Club. When we go so slowly and use more questions than we ever thought we could in a million years, our board cleans up real nice! Hmmm!

    1. Yeah when our instruction is undisciplined with lots of point and pause stuff all over the board, it then appears on the board as shallow and wide, and the learning by the kids is shallow. Fewer words bring the narrow and deep quality.

  8. Andrea Westphal

    It was great finally getting to meet a lot of you at NTPRS last week. Thank you Ben and Skip for the Wednesday night coaching session. After three years of struggling, I finally feel like I am gaining some confidence in my TPRS skills. I am going to try and make it a point to contribute more this year. That’s easy to say before school starts and the madness begins. Thank you all for the continual support because it would be impossible to do this alone.

  9. …that’s easy to say before school starts and the madness begins….

    This is a huge thing to say. We must keep ever in our minds that in our schools it is no less than that – madness, whether it is consciously designed that way or not by those in charge. Some of what we do would drive a normal person nuts, drive Ghandi nuts. So we have to remember that we are not alone in the madness. It is a universal, or at least a national madness. It’s not us. We are doing the best we can on a crazy stage. There is no sane school. It has happened slowly to our national disgrace. Some really small people are in big positions of authority and they should not be. The real leaders are few. This thread came up in April, by the way. We can’t say it enough. We are not the ones who are crazy, and so when we feel that way we must stop and feel the truth – we are teaching in very very difficult conditions.

  10. Just in time training. I have not been active on the board but I’m full steam ahead with CI this year. So many ups and downs but this board has provided great support. My kids have gotten in a rut with responding to questions and I have as well. I have started to see some students not acquiring the key phases after a week of circling and story. I will use these rules to break the cycle. I’m also guilty of a messy board.

  11. And Hayne for years SLOW has been the star word of what we do. SLOW this, SLOW that. SLOW everywhere.

    But SLOW is only one of the two prongs needed for acquisition. Staying in Bounds is the other one. Together they get the job done.

    If you want proof, take a really really simple story tomorrow, or just do a little PQA, and have the entire text consist of about four sentences – the whole thing. Then take a super long amount of time to circle it into existence.

    Go much slower than you usually do. Make sure there are not more than a few new words to them. Just go as slowly as you can and stay in bounds better than you ever thought you could.

    And try to not write more than once or twice on the board. Use slow in-bounds circling to go so much slower than you usually do that you that it makes you feel very very uncomfortable.

    Then watch what happens. The kids won’t be uncomfortable – they will be happy because they understand. Make yourself uncomfortable so that they don’t have to. When you do that, you should get that uniform choral yes/no/one word set of loud answers from the class. Watch them carefully. They will all be up around 4 on jGR.

      1. Sabrina Sebban-Janczak

        I’m not sure where to post this but actually I think this is the perfect place for it since it deals with comprehension . I am trying to remember that catch phrase leitmotiv that Blaine uses all the time when it comes to making sure the students have acquired a structure. It goes something along the lines: you know they have acquired the structures when they are able to ——-,———– and without hesitation ( that s the only part I remember). I can’t remember the first parts and it’s driving me crazy, I looked in Blaine’s green bible but cannot find it.
        I think I’m starting to develop OCD. Anyone knows what I am talking about?

  12. Glad you posted this article Ben and perfect timing as I took one more glance at the PLC before resting up to go into my second week of CI. My new goal this week after reading this: SLOW DOWN. I had mess all over my board this week during OWI. Clean board, minimal new structures, and SLOW starting tomorrow!

  13. I had mess all over my board for nine years dude. And I still go too fast. We all do. You’ll get it. Just look at your board after class and vow not to do it again. Those kids don’t know the language. Keep that in mind. You can do it. Week 2 – yea!

  14. Annemarie Orth

    I sometimes give all the markers to a student so that I won’t write any more on the board. I totally forget that my students aren’t proficient. And I often go too fast. After we do a story, the students assess themselves on the rules and then they asses me on my role in it all, and my greatest issue is circling slowly and staying inbounds. It’s a good reminder when I hear it form my students. We assess the heck out of them, why can’t they do it about us?

    1. Annemarie,

      THAT is totally cool!
      I will take and implement your idea to have my kids assess me on my speed and comprehensibility starting today!
      If I have to leave it up to the administrators to accurately assess me on that , it’ll never happen b/c they don’t get it but the kids DO GET IT. Plus kids are brutally honest. Why didn’t I think about that before?

  15. OK James are you following this mini-thread? Somebody PLEASE make up an assessment rubric for teachers by kids on our speed and comprehensibility and post it here as a comment and I will beg James to write it up in a flow chart for the above rubric hard link. This is – allow me to say it again Annemarie bc you said it first here about two years ago – poignantly badass.

Leave a Comment

  • Search

Get The Latest Updates

Subscribe to Our Mailing List

No spam, notifications only about new products, updates.

Related Posts

Stendra Super Force generico all’ingrosso

Stendra Super Force generico all’ingrosso Valutazione 4.6 sulla base di 352 voti. Nome del prodotto: Stendra Super Force Categoria: Disfunzione Erettile Nome commerciale: Extra Super

The Problem with CI

To view this content, you must be a member of Ben’s Patreon at $10 or more Unlock with PatreonAlready a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to

CI and the Research (cont.)

To view this content, you must be a member of Ben’s Patreon at $10 or more Unlock with PatreonAlready a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to

$10

~PER MONTH

Subscribe to be a patron and get additional posts by Ben, along with live-streams, and monthly patron meetings!

Also each month, you will get a special coupon code to save 20% on any product once a month.

  • 20% coupon to anything in the store once a month
  • Access to monthly meetings with Ben
  • Access to exclusive Patreon posts by Ben
  • Access to livestreams by Ben