Small Addition to jGR With Examples

To view this content, you must be a member of Ben's Patreon at $10 or more
Already a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to access this content.



13 thoughts on “Small Addition to jGR With Examples”

  1. Tomorrow, I am switching to this on my *super important* classroom behavior poster, just because I think this particular breakdown is super-clear.

    I like it! Plus, parents will see it tomorrow night at back-to-school night and they will understand it, too.

    Thanks, Ben!! This will help so much.

  2. It stands for jen’s Great Rubric and then I wanted to make sure I could access that here fast so I decided to label it as a kind of second post to the final version of the rubric, thus jGR 2. I even made a category for it so I could just click on it to find it. To me, it’s a breakthrough of monstrous proportions, or could you tell?

  3. Ben,

    Your comments are bad ass! I explained them again today to my students. We must demand that they show up and be engaged. For so long, I was like a farmer throwing out seeds to see what took. I really needed to make a change. This blog with everyone here gives me the confidence and power that I need to do it for real. Not the BS that I did half-heartedly because I was afraid, but I think this awesome group is a powerful place that we can point to. It has authority, it has power, it has strength that I wouldn’t have on my own, I can point to this work and say that I am part of a PLC that we are following the standards and our practices are vetted out by some of the best teachers out there. Wow, it is empowering.

  4. Well, just know that I and many others, if not all of us, have been that afraid teacher. We know the fear, brother, and I don’t know how else but through trust in community and free and open discussion that we can solve these problems.

    So many of us think that we have to solve all the problems of teaching alone – that was what I did, but it is impossible. I love working together like this. The jGR itself, for me, is the biggest of many breakthroughs we have worked on together.

    Jen’s rubric pretty much guarantees discipline, in one document. It guarantees that I have focused students in a way that I have never had before. Pay attention and contribute or get a C or below, is the message, and the C is if you are really smart.

    This stuff, as you say David, actually and atypically has teeth that bite. It is inspired. And it came from one of us, in this safe place. If jen had written it on the moretprs list I would most likely have missed it, bc the discussion that led up to it would not have been so focused as the discussions we get going here.

  5. PLC friends, I am totally on board with the jGR for many reasons, but there’s ONE concern I have, maybe I missed it in someone else’s comments:

    What about the really quiet, reserved, terrified students for whom it’s a big stretch to make their voice heard? The rubric is great for pushing kids who are naturally louder, more boisterous, etc. But we all have the quiet ones, and I just don’t want to give them the message that it’s sink-or-swim, participate actively or fail. Anyone else figure this one out??

  6. There are two answers I would offer Ben. The first one addresses the rare, really quiet ones with high intelligence:

    Yes absolutely we stay out of their face with jGR. Ted Kimbrough, now a medical doctor, I believe, years ago was that kid. And I have a few now. What to do with those kids?

    O.K. now let’s make this simple, and this is my answer only on what to do with these kids – there may be others. You look in the kid’s face and see the eyes, right? And the fear is there, right? But you see the intelligent responses to your teaching and you also see the quiz grades right? You know lots is happening, you just can’t see it.

    So those eyes are the answer. They are participating. In the eyes are the beginning hope movement responses of the whole body. They are the beginning of the wave of these kids being involved in life and coming out of their fear, which they carry everywhere.

    These kids are some of us a few decades ago. They are the children standing next to the bikes in the growing up wars of life and all they can do is put their hands on the handlebars and they are scared beyond fear. They are wanting to but not able to show up outwardly in life. They are trapped miners.

    But, I submit to you one crucial question. Are they involved? Are they not just restricted by some kind of plastic wrap that is inhibiting their self expression, down there in their minds/mines? Is the flower that they will become one day just not able to grow right now in that outward way?

    And so the question becomes do we rip off the plastic wrap or do we keep teaching to the eyes until that plastic wrap loosens up and comes off on its own?

    That is my answer and what I do with those kids. I let them hide. Now here is the crucial point:

    I also take them aside and tell them (I’ve done this with about two kids now so far this year) that they will get an A in the class no matter what and to relax about the grade. I’ve mentioned this before. I tell them that I get what is going on and that they can get involved more when they want, but they don’t have to now.

    Some teachers would be horrified at this. Some – not us – would even try to get them to speak in the TL. But jGR involves no forced output of any kind and is for the good of the class and may not be for the good of these few kids who fit your description above, Ben. So that’s my first answer.

    We teach the kid first and we differentiate with them as well as those at the other end of the spectrum, those who can’t process fast but try. We differentiate. It is as if they are flawed in a weird way, like God is taking away their ability to speak or something. But He won’t do that forever, he is only doing it now.

    And we are being used in that way, do you see, to help draw the kid out into life where, in spite of the fear inflicted by others/parents/teachers/life itself, we are there to be patient, smile, and wait years if we have to for our flowers to take root in the firm and rich soil of our classrooms, and grow into trust of life.

    To do otherwise, to grade these few kids using the rubric and forcing output would be horrible for all involved. So yes there is no exception to forced output, if we want our flowers to grow at their own rate, the natural rate, the rate that brings them safety. So we do it that way.

  7. Ben the second answer describes the kids of average intelligence and not the rare highly intelligent ones, which I addressed above.

    So I am trying to state that there are two kinds of non-responsive kids – those whose cardboard cutout demeanor is made of fear (addressed above) and those who can do more but choose not to out of a kind of teenage arrogance and pride and a certain kid of teenage defiance, which, I agree, has its base in fear but somehow is different from the rare kid I describe above. What about those kids? Do we hold them accountable? Yes.

    My own reaction to that more commonly occurring kid is to give them the 2 and make them work the plastic wrap off by themselves a little. I know the difference between the rare kid above and the more common kid who is the second type of non-participant, and I make kids of this second type show up more because I know they can.

    We have to be able to tell the difference, of course, between the type 1 kids and the type 2 kids. I’ll leave this idea at that and wait for your response. But do you agree that there are two types of non-participants in our classes and that some need to be exempt – the type 1 kids above, and then this second type, who need to have jGR applied fully to get them to grow because that is what they need?

    Specifically, the type 2 kids normally would earn a 2 at this early point in the year and then they wold be set up to work in class for the 3 because, unlike the type 1 kid, they CAN get on the bike and they CAN unwrap the plastic wrap and they are NOT stuck in a mine. I think I have expressed this clearly and I hope so. We do need to see this difference and be able to apply it when we use jGR. What do you think?

    (Getting any bike rides in out there? Got any jobs out there in California? Half time or one class a day? Slavic is thinking of coming back home, right back where I started from after a strange life long detour to the east. I miss my peeps.)

  8. I had one of these highly intelligent quiet kids come to me the other day concerned about their participation (jGR here) grade. It was lower than last year. They want an A. I told her that I get that she understands, but I also need to be able to OBSERVE that she understands, given that this is the participation/interpersonal component of her grade. I stated that she need not become louder or more boisterous, but just do gestures when I ask, respond, and above all, show me with her eyes that she is getting it all. (I also stated that I would take into consideration her concerns and that I would try to see via other indicators her participation.) This week has been great for her, has kind of pulled her out of that allowed nonchalance, and got her responding and keeping eye contact better than ever. It worked in this case.

    Maybe a way to separate those two types of non-responsive students Ben mentions above is to encourage disappointed (with Participation grade) students to come talk to us privately about this. We know, if we are honest with them and if we push them to be honest with themselves, which students we are dealing with.

  9. I had to post grades so I didn’t incorporate that new 12 range. Now have six more weeks to reflect on it. As it turned out, keeping the old 10 scale but dropping the weight of jGR down to 30% got the numbers really in the right place. I may just keep it. It’s fair, I don’t inflate the jGR grades, which is my biggest concern, and all is good.

Leave a Comment

  • Search

Get The Latest Updates

Subscribe to Our Mailing List

No spam, notifications only about new products, updates.

Related Posts

The Problem with CI

To view this content, you must be a member of Ben’s Patreon at $10 or more Unlock with PatreonAlready a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to

CI and the Research (cont.)

To view this content, you must be a member of Ben’s Patreon at $10 or more Unlock with PatreonAlready a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to

Research Question

To view this content, you must be a member of Ben’s Patreon at $10 or more Unlock with PatreonAlready a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to

We Have the Research

To view this content, you must be a member of Ben’s Patreon at $10 or more Unlock with PatreonAlready a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to



Subscribe to be a patron and get additional posts by Ben, along with live-streams, and monthly patron meetings!

Also each month, you will get a special coupon code to save 20% on any product once a month.

  • 20% coupon to anything in the store once a month
  • Access to monthly meetings with Ben
  • Access to exclusive Patreon posts by Ben
  • Access to livestreams by Ben